What Pros And Cons Can You Expect From A Cedar Shake Roof?

Different roofing materials come with their fair share of pros and cons. But for many homeowners, the advantages of cedar shake roofing far outweigh its disadvantages. When considering cedar shake roofing, you need to look at various factors like your location, climate, budget, maintenance commitment, and your home’s surroundings.

The Pros of Cedar Shake Roofing

Cedar shake roofing offers many benefits, including:

Energy Efficiency

If you need a roofing material with incredible insulation, then cedar shake is your best bet. It not only retains warmth during colder winter months but also reflects heat during hotter summer months. This helps your air conditioning and energy bills from escaping through the roof.

Resistant to Storms

Unlike traditional asphalt shingles that can be dented during hailstorms, cedar shakes won’t bruise when pelted by large chunks of ice or hail. Due to their strength, they also withstand high winds.


With proper regular maintenance, cedar shake roofs can last as long as 50 years, or even more.


Although some shingles are three-dimensional in design, their appearance is often flat. Instead, cedar shakes offer a textured appearance to your roof, complementing many architectural styles. The enhanced aesthetics can also boost your home’s resale value and attract potential buyers when you need to sell your home.

Cons of Cedar Shakes

Here are a few notable downsides of cedar shake roofing:

High Cost

Cedar shake roofing is generally more expensive than asphalt shingles. Due to its green aspect, cedar shake is more costly and requires additional expertise for installation. However, the added cost can be offset by increased home value and enhanced energy savings.

Additional Maintenance

If you opt for a cedar shake roofing system, you will need to be proactive in maintaining it. You must regularly clear excessive leaves and other debris from the roof to allow your cedar shakes to breathe and keep looking great. Ice dams may also damage cedar shakes during winter, so you must schedule quick repairs to prevent further damage.

The Verdict

Depending on your area’s weather situation and personal preference, you can weigh the benefits and downsides of cedar shakes roofing and make an informed choice. Overall, the benefits of cedar shake far outweigh its downsides. Working with a trusted local roofer can help shed more light on your best options based on your unique situation. At Pinnacle Roofing, we have decades of experience installing, replacing, and maintaining cedar shake roofs in the Capital Region of New York and Southern Vermont. Contact us today to learn whether cedar shakes can be ideal for your home!

Call Us Today